Apology by Catholic Church ‘shallow’

Cardinal John Dew described the abuse as unacceptable and indefensible, and said the church was deeply sorry. Photo: ODT files

An apology from the Catholic Church to abuse survivors has been slammed as shallow and only intended to satisfy the general public.

Cardinal John Dew made the apology, the first formal apology to victims, at the Royal Commission into Abuse in Care yesterday on behalf of the bishops and congregational leaders in New Zealand.

He said the church could offer no excuses for the actions that caused harm, and the abuse was perpetrated by people, such as priests, brothers and sisters and lay people that victims should have been able to trust.

He acknowledged the abuse caused pain, and trauma which continued to have an impact on the lives of victims.

But a Dunedin abuse survivor, and Male Survivors Otago spokesman, Michael Chamberlain said the apology meant little.

It was very, very shallow. He was just reading a couple of sentences to satisfy the general public.

Michael said

Many aspects of this week’s commission testimony from various church representatives had left him speechless, he said.

Those giving evidence had been quizzed on the process in which survivors’ claims were investigated by the Catholic Church’s National Office for Professional Standards.

That revealed confusing and inconsistent processes, Mr Chamberlain said.

Challenging would be an understatement.

Mr Chamberlain said he felt this week’s hearings would have left Catholic Church abuse survivors re-traumatised and angry.

He renewed calls for an independent body to investigate claims of abuse by religious institutions.

Article by Daisy Hudson